click for bigger fonts
Ok, appreciable move Gov! I'm waiting for the bill to become the law. And when it becomes the law, lest we not let this go the way of the numerous "laws" we have around us just for the namesake of it. Laws that are around just to encourage the public to break them...The Helmet and seat-belt rule, smoking in public places, ban on plastics to name a few.
Civic sense is not something which can be taught or practiced overnight. Kerala holds an august image as being one of the cleanest states in India, if not the cleanest. We take pride in our well maintained homes and apartments, our cities are still spotless (!) when in Indian perspective, we're given proper toilet training and not the field/railway track training, our city skylines are the prettiest in India and even the shanties we brand as slums are by far the best among the worst. Do you disagree?
The above image of the longest and prettiest skyline in Kerala, the Marine Drive waterfront in Cochin speaks about itself. Well maintained exteriors, no pillow covers, towels or undies hung up to dry in the balconies, and in fact most apartments and housing estates do have rules in place which helps to keep up the aesthetics of the complex.
Still, we're still stuck in the lower primary levels when it comes to acceptable standards of environmental hygiene & civic obedience. I learned a few lessons myself when I migrated outside the comfort zones of my country for the first time, the major crash course being on civic sense and law-abiding. I learned to use the litter bin for even the bubble gum, not to spit around as if the whole world is a wash-basin , to queue up to alight the public bus, to drive on the correct lane at the right speed, to brake whenever I see the amber turn on instead of the age-old habit of accelerating harder...
Not that I'm whinging about our practices back in Kerala.. I still wear 'mundu' at home and not Bermuda, I'm still comfortable eating with my hand and I still speak Malayalam and not the Ranjini Haridas 'maliyalum'.. Just in case some of you think, "oh, this guy is acting the 'sayippu' when he shook hands with a few white men..", its not that way! ;)
The curious thing is that it all came naturally to me because I was trained precisely so as a kid... I remember how my lower primary school teachers taught us to walk only on the footpath, to form the queue while getting into the school bus, not to spit on the road and sidewalks, proper disposal of the lunch-box remains, hand and body hygiene and what not? So where did I, as an individual, lose all those finer qualities? Now, I'm looking for someone to blame when mostly the fingers are all pointed towards myself.
To be honest, in India we practice bits and pieces. I've been reprimanded by a cop in Mangalore for crossing the road when the pedestrian signal was red, I patiently waited in the long queue to get into the BEST bus in Mumbai, I was part of the group which was fined in Mysore Zoo for plastic littering. All valuable education, but transgressed as soon as I landed back in aamchi Trivandrum! I've seen efforts by Bangalore Police to train drivers in lane driving in 2004 but the story was nonetheless the same when I went there last year. So the lesson to be learned is that we as human beings get naturally conditioned by the environment we live in. Simple as that.
Formulating the law is the easiest part, implementing it is the hardest. Kerala authorities learned it the hard way when the 100% sensible helmet rule was brought down to its knees and then driven to the gullies by the 100% literate Kerala society with the help of the demi-God media. It is anybody's guess where this new law will end up. It is unclear who is going to implement this law when the local self Govts apparently have enough on their plate now to look out for more garbage. The silver lining is that we already have the resources and help at hand to ascertain the abiding of this law, through Kudumbasree.Kudumbashree is perhaps the illustrious example of how proper planning can bring about wonder changes to the society. In addition to the social empowerment and upliftment of women and initiating consistent income to the weaker households, it has opened up a channel to solve our most discerning problem: protecting our environment through solid waste management. (Please click the link to see how these women service our cities to keep them clean)
This is how this unique initiative by the State Poverty Eradication Mission may change the way Keralaites see their surroundings.
The Hindu, Sept 7, 2009
Once the Kudumbasree takes over the collection, each house will be given a report card for marking the nature of waste. Segregated and non-segregated waste disposals from the households will be marked in the card. Houses that do not give the waste to the waste handlers will also be identified. With the waste disposals of the households profiled, the ones that dump waste on the roads could be easily identified. The Kudumbasree units are being brought into the picture to ensure that waste is never dumped on the roads.A monthly fee of Rs. 50 each will be collected from each house.
So here is our model! Once the scope of their work is expanded from residential areas to managing the waste from commercial enterprises, a huge chunk of the litter menace in our ponds, canals and roads could be cordoned off. Ask the Corporation of Trivandrum who under-estimated the residents of their city. The Corporation barricaded the Amayizhanjan Canal with wire meshes to prevent dumping of waste into it. So what did the citizens do? They filled up the garbage in polythene bags and flung it over the 10-feet high wire barricade, right into the canal! Well, with Kudumbasree the authorities feel they could now shortlist such smart offenders.
And their modus operandi will solve another headache our agencies had w.r.t waste treatment: segregation of waste. This may open up avenues for the facilitation off recycling and reuse of materials, thereby taking a step closer to the Green initiatives which are gaining momentum.
I wish them good luck! And applause to whoever is behind the virgin initiative.
A much more proactive measure have to come from the local Govts in this matter. Charging & fining the defaulting residents and establishments is a first step towards aligning the practices of residents towards decency, but it should be after the proper support measures are in place. It wouldn't be too impractical or difficult to put up litter bins on public places (like the one in the right pic) with the support of commercial establishments. With more Kudumbasree Units on the job, the processing and disposal of the waste won't be a big issue.
On the same lines, it would be prudent if the local authorities assume a firm stand against the defacing of our highways and cities by these banners, arches and ads. Sure they are avenues of revenue for the Panchayats & Municipalities but at what cost? Most of the time the political flags freely adorn the roundabouts, traffic islands and road dividers without any consent from any local body. A true eyesore in any sense for such a tourism-savvy place, but anyone bothered?
About lane driving and matters related to the road sense, its one tough job to crack the routine. The Highway Police did manage to make the motorists obey the "do not cross the yellow line" law sometime back by using the tough hands of the law, perhaps the next thing to do is to crack down on speeding. Forcing lane driving could be a joke for the simple reason that there are no lanes markings on many of our roads.
So the simple fact is that as Keralites we are not so bad as the rest of our country, but we still have a lot of scope for improvement. When our bad practices start draining our pockets we will be forced to put a chain to it. This is a lifestyle no one would be complaining about adopting from the West, or even the East. Guess why they say 'Singapore is a Fine City' , read this one from blogger Ajay Prasad and find out...
Speaking about hygiene and filth and citizens with civic sense, I learned that the West could be well as bad. Have a glance at the pix below; the one below is Downtown Los Angeles...
and these 'gentlemen' are making themselves known in Melbourne, Australia. May be under the influence but still, I don't envy the behaviour or the surroundings, would you?






its time some strong laws against littering and dirtying the environment and streets is brought up. also the law should be pan- India and not restricted to some city/state.
ReplyDeleteso well put a post..you echo exactly my sentiments...and the sad part is when we tell someone not to throw the banana skin to the road while travelling everyone looks at us like "avan evidinnu vannavannaa..."..when our intent is genuinely to adapt good practices...Following rules of the land is something we indians still have not learned...the only way is heavy fines and uncorrupt policemen to enforce it..
ReplyDeleteI wonder how effective it will be.
ReplyDeleteAs you mentioned all good rules (helmet, smoking in public, seat belt..) have already disappeared into oblivion. Our media is too sympathetic (there were editorials on how inconvenient it is to drive with helmets in peak traffic), people are too unwilling and politicians.. well they have "cattle class" and "austerity drives" to think about.
The problem with our country, IMHO, is
1) It is too easy going. You spit on the road - no problem. You pee on the road - no problem. You put posters anywhere - no problem. You write whatever news you want - no problem......
Who would want to give away this vulgar freedom for some "idealistic" civic sense!!
2) There is no alternative. If nature calls, then the option for most of us is to reach home as soon as possible or to attend the call at the nearest isolated (not necessarily) place. Public toilet - is another discussion topic in itself. Where are the dustbins? How long can one walk around with litter in his hand looking for dustbins? Even the ones with civic sense are demotivated by the lack of infrastructure. Then, as you said, where are the lanes? Where are the good roads for people to follow these speed limits?
I know there is a lot we can do as citizens like not jumping lights, not littering the streets as we please and so on. But cultivating civic sense in people is impossible as long as there is no infrastructure to support it or proper law and motivation to enforce it.
I used to think that most of the people are ignorant or have a 'don't care' attitude about littering. At my church whenever coffee was served in plastic cups(!!!!) the old/young folks used to drop it under every coconut tree in sight. When the new 'Trustee' (the one who manages the church accounts etc, considered to be Trustable :D) bought few bins and placed it under each coconut tree, people dropped it at the bin.
ReplyDeleteMy point was, if there is a bin, there is a way.
There were times, I have dropped some litter on the road when there was no bin in sight or when the bin is overflowing and you cannot move any closer to it because of the stench !
I guess when goverment is planning to slap fines, they should also start efficient clearing of garbage.
Our apartment pays a garbage wala to collect trash. We pay him, he collects thrash. Not sure where he drops it !!!
Kerala Govt needs to be complimented for making an effort.
ReplyDeleteAt the same time,let us not forget that we have plenty of laws for whatever.....where is the will to implement the laws?
It is really a good step. But the problem in Kerala is never with great idea or it's initial implementation. The problem is how long they can sustain this.
ReplyDeleteIt is so good to hear all these.But my question is will it remain in the papers for ever or they will impliment it.
ReplyDeleteWhat i feel is changes should start from the root.Elders and youngsters should be a modal to next generation by keeping there house and sorroundings clean and obeying laws ,rules and regulations.
But i still feel compared to other places in india,kerala(cochin is an exception)is far better.though that is not an excuse for further steps
Lets hope kerala govnmnt try there best to keep there promises
@ I still wear 'mundu' ......ROFL, good one :)
@ Philip, of course it should be pan-India. The right way is to deal with it state by state, and Kudumbasree is a good example all the states could adopt.
ReplyDelete@ Mathew, lol that true. To be honest, if you're indicating when you change the lane on road, people are going to look at you as if you're a clown. ;)
@ Layman, good points. The wise thing to do is to crack one behaviour at a time. I agree, instilling road sense is the most difficult one but env hygiene is a compulsory area we need to get out acts right on .
@ xylene, I'm not sure about Bangalore but Kerala cities have their own Garbage Treatment plants in place which is a big boon. As you put it, if there is a bin there is a way :)
@ Chowlaji, good Q. Well, lets see how the Kerala Gov implement this one.
@ Dreamer, we have to sustain this as we have found a way of dealing with it now. So I hope to see a change this time.
@ Anish Thomas, Most Indian cities are dumps, except perhaps B'lore, Chandigarh or Gandhinagar. Doesn't mean Kerala is spotless though ;)
Great blog, man...Very much true, we Mallus must be a race of people with lowest civic sense.
ReplyDeleteA few instances that I witnessed
One fine Sunday Morning few people where standing in a bus stop. I was one among them. We were standing away from the stop and towards the place where road turns.
So buses were stopping almost in turning point causing a problem for other vehicles. A police man saw this and asked us(politely) to move to the proper bus stop. We were moving when an old woman started shouting at the cop for no reason. Then few other people joined her. I was wondering 'these so called decent people are far worse goondas than the orginal ones'.
Another instance. A fine morning. When there is no traffic blocks vehicles rush around at high speed. I saw a woman casually passing through red signal in a scooter with a child at her back. She should have been there in some Hollywood stunt movies. Because passing through a red light with a child possibly your own when there is a great possiblity of some vehicle coming in from a different road (where the signal is green) can smash you to pulp requires a lot of courage.
If there was some civic sense we could have avoided a lot of road accidents
And I appreciate you for mentioning Kudumbasree. They collect our garbage just to make their ends meet. They make our city a better place. Before this started we used to throw our garbage at an empty plot near by. But the sad and shocking part is there are well off middle class people who refuse to pay them 30 rupees a month.
The greatest problem with mallus is we are too much of a socialist. Hence breaking the laws is the law....
great article aliyaaaaa..
ReplyDeleteloved the analysis and the emotions behind the post!!!!!
you are right in everything you say. We indians just cannot follow civic rules and though many people take the effort to keep clean, the general public do not believe in it.........
it is almost a complete contrast to maybe 500 years back. we were one of the cleanest people in the world at that time when much of europe passed thru one plague or the other........
but yes, it starts young when we should instill in children the importance of being clean!!!!
a great post!!!!!
As a policy I dont litter....
ReplyDeleteThe day I decided nt to litter I found tht nearest dustbin ws never far away...I travel often by Indian railways and I hv never felt the need to dump things outside the window....its sad to notice hw rail lines are littered with plastic cups and chip packets....
Last weekend wen travelling from Kerala to Bangalore as I put my empty plastic tea cup back to my bag...one guy commented sayng "verde style kanichuttu vella avishyam ondu" (sorry my translietrary skills r nt gr8)
Many people nt only unappreciate bt also ridicule few of us who go an extra mile nt to litter....
Alappuzha canals are painful reminder who hw littering damages ecology....these days canals closely resembles gutters.....
Scorpio, another thaughtfull article from you. Well one point of you struck me the most was about our school days, defenitly we were all taught to be and behave like a good citizen, we, most of us here have good civic sence, but as u said our laws are not enough for us to make it practlcal!! we have seen us Indians doing all those unhygenic things in India and when once we are out in a new country were there are strict laws against this, we are the most obediant citizens there, we wont feel any difficulty to behave like that, because we have it inside us, only thing is that there is nobody to control us here in India, and lazyness being a human behavior our attitude changes to "ah cheylega" tone!! so thats the reason why you were fined in Mysore Zoo!! and not because that u dont have civic sence!! we must have strict laws so that we can rejuvinate our rudimentary Civic sence!!
ReplyDelete@ Jon, I've broken the red light on a few occasions, especially the pedestrian ones but not intentionally but because I was preoccupied. ;) Doesn't make a difference in front of the law though but in Kerala it is done deliberately.
ReplyDelete@ Interesting point there! About Europe after the plague..I dread the thought of a plague anywhere now but there was a documentary about Surat after the plague and how well the people and authorities have changed after the infamous epidemic.
@ Small talk, hahaha thats the problem here. People get ridiculed if they follow the law and so we're forced to follow the "law of the land", that is lawlessness!
@ Sanju, true buddy, our training get lost somewhere along our lives and we forget the finer characters instilled into us. Well, our society has transformed us to be like all this.
A great post as usual…. Nd when these same people are placed in another environment they automatically do the right thing… in Kerala, we are quick to make rules but they are never enforced…
ReplyDeleteit is great to read about Kudumbasree…
I guess with a little bit of push, awarenes, and organization, with categorized litter bins at every needed locations, we keralites could do a good job. We just need that small push. We are willing and we are aware to some extent.
ReplyDeleteThere is responsibility for both the people and the government. Govt has to ensure that waste is collected daily from households and disposed of properly. The main idea should be not to persuade people to throw it away on the roadside. In Trivandrum I have observed that waste is not collected from houses daily. And as Mathew commented "ivan evidathu karanaada" attitude of the common man must change. I liked this post...
ReplyDeleteInteresting read, thanks.
ReplyDeleteGreat post! You are spot on when you say that Civic sense cannot be taught, it just has to be realized by each. Dumping waste in somebody else'vacant compund is another one. In an attempt to ensure cleanliness in one's house, we end up duping waste in somebody else's compound. I see that happening frequently in Cochin.
ReplyDeleteThoughtful and heartfelt post..
ReplyDelete"The greatest problem with mallus is we are too much of a socialist. Hence breaking the laws is the law...." Exactly the problem and the solution in itself... :)
Thanks for this post Scorpio.
ReplyDeleteThe idea is good, but this is going to be a tough law to implement, there was to be a parallel initiative to spread awareness too. Yes, Kudumbasree going a great job, hats off to whoever conceived the idea.
btw, here's a link you may be interested in - http://tidycity.org/
Hello
ReplyDeleteI like this blog because from this blog I have got so many new information about different topics.Its really very nice article to read.Thank you for sharing this with us.
glucosamine
^^ Thanks for the responses ladies and gentlemen. :)
ReplyDelete@ Nitin, I know and follow the activities of Tidycity and appreciate the works you guys are doing :applause:
Accordіng to the Wall Stгeet Јournal, and so οn.
ReplyDeleteAnуοne armed with thiѕ аρplicatіоn,
and a valid lοgin and passωord is necessary to
clеаr out your Internet history fгom the Ѕafari browser of the
iPod partѕ and iphone parts to гeplacе.
With the recent іnnоvation of the nеw smartphοne.
ӏndeed, аnаlysts say, Aрple's booming voice, possibly in the person of digital assistant Siri, will drown out all others.
Have a look at my page :: echipcongnghe.com
Aρple set its еуes on those ѕmаllеr-tablet dοllаrs.
ReplyDeleteMs Cаmpіns, who liνes іn Ѕan Frаncisco.
Or pay $15 for 250 megabуtеs of Internet datа; when it runs out, you
can alѕo dοωnload а neω
Jambοx сompаnion thаt can inform
you of upcoming еventѕ in your phone's calendar.
Also visit my web-site: Ipad
0 Plus tο the Galaxy S3 offeгѕ more than thе Аsсend D
ReplyDeleteQuad XL and blackberry
S3. 1-inсh counteгpart Thе 16 GB Galaxy Nοte 10.